Menu

What are frequent sources of instabilities?

This FAQ explains some frequent sources of these instabilities.

Hinges and connections

In most of cases the instabilities are due do errors in the modeling of the connections between elements or in the definition of hinges.
A common mistake is the release of all rotational degrees of freedom aiming at removing bending moment from the beam elements, as shown in the following image: 

SCIA Engineer Frequent sources of instabilities

This setup will allow the beam to rotate on its own axis, leading to instability. The 'fix' degree of freedom should never be released on both extremities of the same beam. Furthermore, a more elegant and effective way to remove bending from beam elements, without using hinges, is to declare them as 'axial only elements', as in the image below.

SCIA Engineer Frequent sources of instabilities


Surface support

Another common source of instability arises when using surface support without specifying a support stiffness in the horizontal direction:

SCIA Engineer Frequent sources of instabilities

Unless the structure his blocked horizontally via additional supports, the C1x and C1y value should never be equal to zero, because in this case the structure is free to move horizontally, thus leading to instability.

 

Instability during nonlinear analysis

In case that the linear analysis run flawlessly while nonlinear analysis stops due to instability, that means that the structure is not able to carry the applied load. In fact, the nonlinear solver can find a solution only when the structure is stable: when the structure is instable (buckling) the nonlinear solver stops. In such cases you should review/change the design of the structure so to allow it to support the applied load.

To confirm that you are facing this case, you should perform a linear stability analysis to check the value of the lowest critical alpha: if this value is close to or lower than 1, it means that the structure will not be able to carry the load when subject to the non-linear analysis.